I don't know how any of that is controversial, and I've been shocking consistent about this position. From oldest to newest:
"Double down on what? I legitimately have no clue what happened here, but I don't think the fact that this OG appears to be an asshole necessarily makes him a lying asshole."
"No, we know nothing, and nothing has been solved."
"I still don't believe that we have enough information to know what happened here"
"As much as this guy does not seem great, he could also be telling the truth. We don't have enough information to really understand what went on so that's my current stance: I don't know."
"That doesn't mean he's lying, it just means we can't prove he's telling the truth."